One of my biggest problems is finding lenses that don't look scary on light eyes.
There's some lush ones on the GEO site and on DollyEye, but it seems like if I order the green ones, they're the only ones that will actually match.
My eyes are a light Aqua (don't be fooled by the dp, photoshop FTW) and...yeah.

Has anyone else had this problem?

For a more natural effect, stick with colors that will blend better with your eye color, like blue and grey. (Some grey lenses can look really dark, almost black, so be sure to research and look online for photos of real people wearing them.)

Also, if you're afraid of your eyes looking too big, look into styles with a minimal enlarging effect, like GEO Ash Wing.

Okay, Thank you =]